School responds to video of lecturer’s anti-Republican rant by banning videotaping

Katherine Timpf
Reporter

Total Shares
This is the CRO SBAR

  • A student filmed Eyon Biddle's anti-Republican rant in February and Campus Reform published the story.
  • The faculty senate responded by explicitly banning video recording without instructor approval.
  • One professor mocked the idea of being "fair and balanced" by asking if she should be required to teach Holocaust denial.
  • University of Wisconsin - Whitewater has changed school policy after a student captured a video of a guest lecturer ranting about his hatred of Republicans — not to prevent such lectures, but rather preventing them from being recorded and exposed.

    On March 11, the Faculty Senate unanimously passed a resolution explicitly banning videotaping in the classroom after the video, recorded by student Kyle Brooks and published by Campus Reform, gained national attention.

    Faculty need to assert our scholarly expertise and right of academic freedom, as the warning to be 'fair and balanced' completely ignored the highly subjective and politicized implication of the phrase “fair and balanced” – am I expected to waste time “teaching” Holocaust denial?”   

    “As you may know, there was an incident of a student making and sharing (on national media) an unauthorized classroom videorecording earlier this month,” Associate Professor of History Nikki Mandell wrote in an email on March 13.

    “Faculty Senate Resolution passed unanimously that reaffirms existing policy which prohibits recording in the class without instructor approval,” it continued.

    The school already had a policy banning recording in place, but that policy “did not have the language of video recording,” the resolution clarified.

    According Mandell’s email, Chancellor Richard J. Telfer said the school would not issue a statement on the incident, but simply reminded instructors to keep a “balanced perspective in the classroom” — a comment Mandell rejected.

    “My editorial comment: Faculty need to assert our scholarly expertise and right of academic freedom, as the warning to be 'fair and balanced' completely ignored the highly subjective and politicized implication of the phrase 'fair and balanced' – am I expected to waste time 'teaching' Holocaust denial?” she stated in the email.

    The lecture in the video was given by Eyon Biddle Sr., the current political and organizing director for SEIU Local 150, and blamed the 2010 Republican landslide election on “white rage.”

    “The context of 2010 was, white rage … white people having to pay for health care for blacks and browns and gays,” Biddle said on Feb. 25.

    Watch the original video here: 

    Follow the author of this article on Twitter @kctimpf

    Katherine Timpf

    Katherine Timpf

    Reporter

    Katherine Timpf is a columnist at Campus Reform. Previously, Timpf worked as a reporter, web editor, and radio personality at The Washington Times. She was also an anchor for NASA's alternative radio station, Third Rock Radio.

    Timpf has appeared on national television news shows, including  America Live with Megyn Kelly and Fox and Friends, and her stories have been featured on several national news outlets, including the Drudge Report. She has been an op ed contributor to publications including the Orange County Register and Investor's Business Daily.

    More By Katherine Timpf

    LATEST TWEETS

    deborah rieck
    @deborahrieck - 59 min ago

    Virginia Tech professor compares Israel to extremist Islamic group ISIS http://t.co/WDEw7zL3s9 via @campusreform

    Carl Kieck
    @CarlKieck - 3 hours ago

    Follow CAMPUS REFORM: @campusreform "17 % of Harvard’s graduating class admits to cheating in academics ..." http://t.co/lWJk6gk2iB

    Carl Kieck
    @CarlKieck - 3 hours ago

    17 percent of Harvard’s graduating class admits to cheating in academics http://t.co/GnGeti1ztz via @campusreform HARVARD GRADUATES CHEATS?

    tannngl
    @tannngl - 3 hours ago

    UPenn Professor: accreditation of religious schools a 'scandal' http://t.co/XPTeBElKNJ via @campusreform

    Sam Won
    @SamObiWon - 4 hours ago

    "@campusreform: 17 percent of @Harvard’s graduating class admits to cheating in academics: http://t.co/I9j0aPjW67 by @kctimpf"|so really 35%

    Sam Won
    @SamObiWon - 4 hours ago

    @campusreform @kctimpf @Harvard which means the actual percentage is closer to 50%.

    gobo
    @gobospring - 5 hours ago

    @campusreform @Harvard @kctimpf Given the quality of politicized academics taught in the Ivyswhat does it matter.

    Latest 30 Articles