Free speech experts slam 'vague' policy policing student social media activity

  • Free speech experts say that more often than not, ambiguous wording in campus speech policies is what leaves students' free speech rights vulnerable.
  • One Minnesota college has come under fire for such language in its online code of conduct.

Technology policies at colleges and universities across the country are becoming increasingly relevant as most have transitioned to online learning during the COVID-19 crisis. Specifically, free speech watchdogs are calling into question one institution's social media policies.

Macalester College's online policy has been named by the Foundation for Individual Rights in Education as one of the most restricting due to its ambiguity. While FIRE focuses on Macalester, however, Speech First President Nicole Neily says Macalester is not alone.

“Without a doubt, Macalester's policies have both the intention and the effect of chilling student speech..."   

[RELATED:  Schools from New York to California shell out money for illegals]

“Macalester is far from unique in asserting jurisdiction over its students' social media posts; dozens (if not hundreds) of schools have similar policies on the books, many of which have been on the books for years (predating the coronavirus),” Neily told Campus Reform.

The computer use policy states, “students should refrain from posting material that is deemed to be criminal; harassing; racially, sexually, ethnically or religiously objectionable; defamatory; obscene; invasive of another s [sic] privacy; or infringing of copyright.” 

“This policy is problematic because it is both vague and overbroad,” explains FIRE.

FIRE argues that the colleges’ use of phrases like “inappropriate” and “objectionable” in such a policy is detrimental to free speech because they are “highly subjective terms that mean different things to different people.”

“While they may legitimately be targeting unlawful conduct like harassment, banning all ‘objectionable’ material necessarily includes protected speech,” the organization explains.

[RELATED:  Emory newspaper urges school to 'rethink' free speech policy amid Syracuse protests]

Neily told Campus Reform that these types of policies are intentionally “chilling” to campus free speech. 

“Without a doubt, Macalester's policies have both the intention and the effect of chilling student speech; given the vagueness of the wording, administrators have tremendous discretionary power to pick winners and losers,” Neily explained, adding that “it's perfectly logical for students to self-censor under such a regime - considering the ideological tilt of college administrators across the country, political and religious opinions very well might be branded ‘harassing’ or ‘objectionable,’ just like they have been at countless other campuses around America.”

Macalester College is a private school that claims to support its students' rights to  free speech, even stating in its student handbook, “students and student organizations are free to examine and discuss all questions of interest to them and to express opinions publicly and privately.” 

“It's disappointing - although not surprising - that a private school claiming to support the values of free expression is preaching one thing yet practicing another - holding schools accountable for breaking promises like this is actually one of the reasons that Speech First launched a private school petition program in mid-April,” Neily said. 

Macalester College did not respond to request for comment in time for publication.

Follow the author of this article on Twitter: @_EverettKatie



STAY INFORMED
Get exclusive access to breaking CampusReform stories as they happen. Sign up below and we'll keep you in the loop.
 Weekly Digest

 Daily Emails

Katie Everett
Katie Everett | Texas Campus Correspondent

Katie Everett is a Texas Campus Correspondent, reporting on liberal bias and abuse for Campus Reform. She is a Senior at Texas A&M University, where she studies Telecommunication with a concentration in Media. She is a Member of Young Women for America and the Young Conservatives of Texas on her campus.

9 Articles by Katie Everett